The Draft, Revisited · 2026
Your draft, regraded
1000 Miles From Home · Through Week 8
The Draft, Revisited
Halfway through the season, the best draft in the league came out of the last row. Everyone else gets to read about it.
Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard has the best draft in the league, and it isn't a debate. Its picks have scored 438.9 points more than their slots produced in a redraft. Nobody else is within shouting distance.
The crime scene is the 157th pick. Kirk Cousins went there, in round 16, and now ranks 14th. Christian Watson went 97th and ranks 10th. Add Brock Purdy from round six and Dak Prescott from round two, and the team named for burying quarterbacks drafted three who all sit inside the redraft's top fourteen. Life, uh, finds a way!
Now the suspicion, because first place doesn't get flowers. The Graveyard's first pick was Christian McCaffrey at fourth overall, and he ranks 12th, so the best drafter in the league whiffed a little exactly where everyone was watching. Halfway through, all of this can still turn. Nobody at the bottom should count on it.
Halfway through the season (through Week 8), every pick graded on what he has scored since, on a curve. Vs par: points above or below what those slots produced in a redraft. From the draft: the share of the team’s started points from its own picks.
| # | Team | Grade | Pts | Vs par | From the draft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard Top grade, but TreVeyon Henderson went 64th and ranks 118th. Even graveyards grow weeds. | A+ | 1554.9 | +438.9 | 78% |
| 2 | The Tasers Lamar Jackson went second and ranks 65th. Still an A. Grade inflation lives. | A | 1332.1 | +284.8 | 89% |
| 3 | Don't Touchdown There Nailed Drake Maye, then Nico Collins went 23rd and ranks 73rd. Round three, fumbled. | A- | 1414.1 | +255.6 | 89% |
| 4 | Hurts, Donut? Nailed the first pick. Then Jadarian Price went 61st and scored 14.0 points. | B | 1358.2 | +203.6 | 72% |
| 5 | Old Goat Rashee Rice went 14th, ranks 98th. Round-14 Michael Wilson is the alibi. | B- | 1156.7 | +30.2 | 65% |
| 6 | What The Buck?! David Montgomery went 48th and ranks 111th. The C-plus is the receipt. | C+ | 1109.2 | +19.4 | 74% |
| 7 | Sunday Scaries A third-round Jaxson Dart has 27.4 points. Matthew Golden can't cover that alone. | C | 1041.2 | −93.8 | 70% |
| 8 | Owen's fave Jeremiyah Love went 15th and ranks 100th. Some favorite. | D+ | 883.3 | −225 | 64% |
| 9 | The Commish Fifth overall, 24.6 points! Just 60% of your started points came from your draft. | D | 935.2 | −227 | 60% |
| 10 | HotOnes18 Jalen Hurts went ninth, ranks 62nd. A.J. Brown went 29th, ranks 133rd. Mild. | F | 821.6 | −289.9 | 72% |
The curve runs from Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard at 438.9 above its slots down to HotOnes18 in the cellar, and only six of ten drafts finished on the right side of zero.
The steals: taken late, playing early
| Player | Team | Went | Ranks | Pts |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kirk Cousins (QB) | Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard | #157 | #14 | 141.1 |
| Bryce Young (QB) | Hurts, Donut? | #121 | #28 | 126.2 |
| Michael Wilson (WR) | Old Goat | #134 | #43 | 108.7 |
| Christian Watson (WR) | Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard | #97 | #10 | 146.8 |
| Matthew Golden (WR) | Sunday Scaries | #110 | #25 | 131.5 |
| Blake Corum (RB) | The Tasers | #142 | #59 | 82.8 |
The busts: early picks, late returns
| Player | Team | Went | Ranks | Pts |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| De'Von Achane (RB) | The Commish | #5 | #129 | 24.6 |
| A.J. Brown (WR) | HotOnes18 | #29 | #133 | 19.1 |
| Jaxson Dart (QB) | Sunday Scaries | #30 | #123 | 27.4 |
| Travis Etienne Jr. (RB) | HotOnes18 | #32 | #121 | 30.9 |
| Jeremiyah Love (RB) | Owen's fave | #15 | #100 | 53.4 |
| Rashee Rice (WR) | Old Goat | #14 | #98 | 56.3 |
Kirk Cousins, a 16th-rounder, has outscored seven of the ten first-round picks, which makes him the golden ticket in the last Wonka bar on the shelf. The Commish took De'Von Achane fifth; he ranks 129th. Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard took Kirk Cousins 157th; he ranks 14th.
The draft as it should have gone: everyone drafted, ranked by what they’ve scored.
| # | Player | Pts | Went | Drafted by |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jaxon Smith-Njigba (WR) | 220 | #1 | Hurts, Donut? |
| 2 | Joe Burrow (QB) | 169.6 | #13 | What The Buck?! |
| 3 | CeeDee Lamb (WR) | 168.3 | #11 | Sunday Scaries |
| 4 | Drake Maye (QB) | 160.9 | #3 | Don't Touchdown There |
| 5 | Kenneth Walker III (RB) | 160.1 | #22 | The Tasers |
| 6 | D'Andre Swift (RB) | 150.7 | #43 | Don't Touchdown There |
| 7 | Trey McBride (TE) | 150.4 | #21 | Hurts, Donut? |
| 8 | Kyren Williams (RB) | 150 | #18 | Don't Touchdown There |
| 9 | Dak Prescott (QB) | 147.9 | #17 | Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard |
| 10 | Christian Watson (WR) | 146.8 | #97 | Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard |
| 11 | Brock Purdy (QB) | 146 | #57 | Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard |
| 12 | Christian McCaffrey (RB) | 144 | #4 | Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard |
Run it back Edge of Tomorrow style and Jaxon Smith-Njigba still goes first; the biggest climb into the top of the board is Christian Watson, taken 97th and now 10th, one of four Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard players in that top twelve. Live, die, repeat, and the Graveyard still wins the do-over.
Every first-round pick, and where he ranks now.
| Pick | Player | Team | Ranks | Pts |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Jaxon Smith-Njigba (WR) | Hurts, Donut? | #1 | 220 |
| #2 | Lamar Jackson (QB) | The Tasers | #65 | 79.1 |
| #3 | Drake Maye (QB) | Don't Touchdown There | #4 | 160.9 |
| #4 | Christian McCaffrey (RB) | Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard | #12 | 144 |
| #5 | De'Von Achane (RB) | The Commish | #129 | 24.6 |
| #6 | Amon-Ra St. Brown (WR) | Owen's fave | #15 | 141 |
| #7 | James Cook III (RB) | Old Goat | #23 | 131.7 |
| #8 | Puka Nacua (WR) | What The Buck?! | #18 | 138.6 |
| #9 | Jalen Hurts (QB) | HotOnes18 | #62 | 80 |
| #10 | Derrick Henry (RB) | Sunday Scaries | #20 | 136.7 |
Not one first-rounder outran his slot (Jaxon Smith-Njigba merely held his), and Lamar Jackson, De'Von Achane and Jalen Hurts were all top-ten picks who now rank somewhere past sixtieth. In space no one can hear you scream; in round one, The Tasers, The Commish and HotOnes18 can.
The best seasons by players nobody drafted.
| Player | Pts | Found by |
|---|---|---|
| Aaron Rodgers (QB) | 117.1 | Sunday Scaries |
| Braelon Allen (RB) | 82.4 | Hurts, Donut? |
| Michael Penix Jr. (QB) | 68.7 | Owen's fave |
| Ollie Gordon II (RB) | 57 | The Commish |
| Alvin Kamara (RB) | 53.5 | Hurts, Donut? |
Nobody drafted Aaron Rodgers, a wizard is never late, and he now sits on Sunday Scaries with 117.1 points, which is the same team that spent a third-rounder on Jaxson Dart.
Kept from last season, so not graded here.
| Player | Team | Pts |
|---|---|---|
| Jahmyr Gibbs (RB) | Hurts, Donut? | 195.8 |
| Josh Allen (QB) | The Commish | 187.8 |
| Bijan Robinson (RB) | Old Goat | 153.3 |
| Jonathan Taylor (RB) | What The Buck?! | 144.2 |
| Ashton Jeanty (RB) | Sunday Scaries | 132.3 |
| Ja'Marr Chase (WR) | Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard | 128.2 |
| Caleb Williams (QB) | HotOnes18 | 97.6 |
| Chase Brown (RB) | Owen's fave | 90.9 |
| Justin Jefferson (WR) | Don't Touchdown There | 86.4 |
| Saquon Barkley (RB) | The Tasers | 50.5 |
Jahmyr Gibbs has 195.8 points for Hurts, Donut?, the keeper that has paid off most, while The Tasers kept Saquon Barkley and got the lowest return on the list, which in Shark Tank terms is a hard pass.
The lesson, halfway through: this draft was won in the rounds nobody watches. Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard took Cousins in round 16, Watson in round ten and Jaylen Warren in round nine, and 78% of its started points come from its own picks. Call it Moneyball for the late rounds.
The other end is grim. The Commish draws the lowest share of its started points from its own draft in the league, and the waiver wire is doing the drafting that pick five didn't. HotOnes18 took the F on third- and fourth-rounders A.J. Brown and Travis Etienne Jr., both on the busts list. A bust can still turn. Week 8 is just the receipt.
Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard dug up a starter in round 16. The Commish dug a hole at pick five.
In another league? : a free sample for theirs, or 20% off the season.
Roll the Tape
End of reel · Bear Essentials AI, LLC
Or try a week free · A weekly newspaper for your fantasy league · Your account · Privacy · Terms