Reel No. 9 · Week 9 · 2026
Your league, reviewed
1000 Miles From Home · Week 9
The Front Page
Unbeaten for eight weeks, then a loss to The Commish by 1.42 with the winning lineup parked on its own bench. Nobody beat the first-place team. Its lineup card did.
Hurts, Donut? walked into Week 9 without a loss and walked out with one. Here is the part that stings: the best lineup on that roster would have won. The lineup it actually started scored 112.6, the lowest total of its season. It went 3-6 against the field. The costliest seat on the bench belonged to Bryce Young, a quarterback, who put up 20.3 while the starters lost by a field goal's worth of nothing. Eight weeks of terrorizing this league, undone by one bad set of clicks. You did this to yourselves!
The Commish, which had beaten Hurts, Donut? five times in 23 previous meetings, pulled the full Hoosiers. It ran a 98.6% lineup, the kind of clean card that steals close games. It also won with a score that beat only four teams in the league, so nobody is engraving anything. Our own line had Hurts, Donut? by 17. Our line would like a word with that bench.
Now the cold water, because we are honest people. Hurts, Donut? is still 8-1 and still has the most points in the league by a mile. Its playoff odds sit at >99%, right where they were last week. One loss did not dent the math. It dented the mystique, and the scores have now dropped two weeks running. The king is fine. The king just looks mortal.
The exit tape: who left early, and whether it mattered.
Clean bill of health. No starter in this league left his game hurt this week, so every ugly number in this edition was produced by healthy players and fully conscious lineup decisions. The trainers got the day off. The managers did not.
Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard posted the week’s high score with a 36.2-point quarterback buried on its bench. The name is a mission statement.It also broke a 3-3 series tie, beating a HotOnes18 lineup that started every right player and lost anyway.
Power score: 60% the season's all-play win rate, 40% the last three weeks' (all-play is how often a team outscored every other team that week). Ties go to points for.
| # | Team | Move | Record | Power |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Hurts, Donut? Still first. Still lost to The Commish. Both are true. | – | 8-1 | 81.5 |
| 2 | Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard Week's high score with a 36.2-point quarterback six feet under. | – | 5-4 | 70.4 |
| 3 | What The Buck?! Best three-week all-play in the league; the record hasn't noticed. | – | 5-4 | 65.6 |
| 4 | Old Goat Up two spots on a full win of borrowed luck. | ▲2 | 6-3 | 53.3 |
| 5 | HotOnes18 Perfect lineup, lost anyway, up two spots, 1% odds. Cruel. | ▲2 | 3-6 | 50.4 |
| 6 | Sunday Scaries Up two spots on an 8-19 recent all-play. Explain that. | ▲2 | 5-4 | 44.1 |
| 7 | The Commish Beat first place and dropped two spots. The rankings saw the tape. | ▼2 | 5-4 | 43.0 |
| 8 | Don't Touchdown There Down four, 5-22 lately, and C.J. Stroud's 35.4 on the bench. | ▼4 | 4-5 | 36.3 |
| 9 | The Tasers Up one spot. Owen's fave politely held the door. | ▲1 | 1-8 | 28.1 |
| 10 | Owen's fave Dead last in power with a full win of luck. Imagine without. | ▼1 | 3-6 | 27.4 |
Don't Touchdown There fell four spots, from fourth to eighth, the biggest move of the week in either direction.
Through Week 9, 4 weeks left, 4 make the playoffs. The rest of the regular season, played 10,000 times from each team's own scores (half season, half last three weeks, pulled toward the league average). Seeds by wins, then points for. Every team's head-to-head record under every team's schedule, averaged. Luck is wins above or below that average; median-game results are left out.
| Team | Record | Playoffs | This week | Luck |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hurts, Donut? | 8-1 | >99% | – | +0.4 |
| Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard | 5-4 | 73% | +11 | −0.8 |
| Old Goat | 6-3 | 67% | +13 | +1 |
| What The Buck?! | 5-4 | 61% | +16 | +0.2 |
| Sunday Scaries | 5-4 | 52% | −1 | +0.2 |
| The Commish | 5-4 | 38% | – | +0.7 |
| Don't Touchdown There | 4-5 | 8% | −33 | −0.3 |
| HotOnes18 | 3-6 | 1% | −5 | −0.7 |
| Owen's fave | 3-6 | <1% | −1 | +1 |
| The Tasers | 1-8 | <1% | – | −1.7 |
Don't Touchdown There fell off a cliff this week, down to 8%, the steepest drop in the league. What The Buck?! made the biggest climb, up to 61%, and suddenly looks like a team that has read the standings. Hurts, Donut? sits at >99% with four weeks left and four playoff spots to hand out. Behind it, Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard holds 73%. Old Goat, last year's champion, is at 67%. The bubble belongs to Sunday Scaries at a coin-flip 52% and The Commish at 38%. Everyone from HotOnes18 down is at 1% or worse, which is a polite way of saying start shopping for draft-party snacks.
The luck story has a clear victim. The Tasers are 1-8 and the unluckiest team in the league, nearly two wins below what an average schedule would have handed them. On Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard's schedule, The Tasers would be 5-4. Old Goat and Owen's fave are the luckiest, each a full win ahead of its average, and Owen's fave should send flowers: on What The Buck?!'s schedule it would be 0-9. Next week is the rose ceremony: Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard against The Commish. A Graveyard win means 88%; a loss drops it to 50%. The Commish goes to 63% with a win and 23% without one.
The season through Week 9. Lineup: points scored as a share of the best lineup each roster could have started. Lost: games the best lineup would have won. Pickups: points started by this season's claims. Trades: points started since, ahead or behind, record below.
| Team | Lineup | Bench | Lost | Pickups | Trades |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HotOnes18 | 96% | 43.7 | 0 | 114.4 | – |
| Hurts, Donut? | 91.8% | 124.4 | 1 | 102.9 | – |
| The Commish | 91.1% | 109.4 | 2 | 261.5 | – |
| Sunday Scaries | 90.6% | 119 | 2 | 200.2 | – |
| Old Goat | 84% | 207.1 | 1 | 259.4 | – |
| What The Buck?! | 83.8% | 214.6 | 3 | 124 | – |
| Don't Touchdown There | 83.3% | 217.7 | 2 | 53 | – |
| Owen's fave | 83.3% | 179.6 | 2 | 212.1 | – |
| Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard | 81.8% | 261.4 | 3 | 84.7 | – |
| The Tasers | 78.2% | 274 | 7 | 26.1 | – |
HotOnes18 sets the best lineups in the league, 96.0% of its best possible all season, and has lost zero games to its own bench. It is 3-6. That's the Bad News Bears with a perfect clipboard. At the other end sits The Tasers, the worst lineup-setters in the league at 78.2%, with 274.0 points left on the bench, the most of anyone. The Tasers have lost seven games their best lineup would have won. Seven! That's seven of their eight losses, and no schedule did that to them.
On the wire, The Commish is the league's best shopper, with 261.5 started points from claims, led by Tyler Shough. Old Goat is right behind on a league-high 20 claims. Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard has made three claims all season and left 261.4 on its bench, so the Graveyard doesn't need new bodies; it needs to dig up the ones it already has. And trades? Not one, by any of the ten teams, all season. This league negotiates like it's afraid of the phone.
| Performer | Pos | Team | Pts |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kenneth Walker III | RB | The Tasers | 36.3 |
| Puka Nacua | WR | What The Buck?! | 35.0 |
| CeeDee Lamb | WR | Sunday Scaries | 33.5 |
| Matthew Golden | WR | Sunday Scaries | 32.4 |
| Ja'Marr Chase | WR | Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard | 31.5 |
| Joe Burrow | QB | What The Buck?! | 29.5 |
| Bucky Irving | RB | HotOnes18 | 28.5 |
| Bijan Robinson | RB | Old Goat | 26.7 |
The best performance of the week went to a team that lost, which makes Kenneth Walker III the Super Bowl commercial everyone loved and nobody remembers the product. Sunday Scaries put two receivers in the top four and still went just 5-4 against the field. Somebody on that roster isn't pulling weight, and it isn't CeeDee Lamb.
Thursday’s line, graded. Favorites covered 3 of 5. Our line, worked out from each team's own scores (half its season average, half its last three weeks, pulled toward the league average early in the season). For bragging rights only.
| Line | Final | Covered | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sunday Scaries −12 | 121–106.2 | Favorite | Under 229 |
| Hurts, Donut? −17 | 112.6–114.1 | Underdog | Under 260.5 |
| What The Buck?! −10 | 136.4–102.1 | Favorite | Over 235 |
| Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard −7 | 138.8–122.6 | Favorite | Over 246 |
| Don't Touchdown There −3 | 104.8–123.8 | Underdog | Under 238.5 |
Our line went 3 of 5 against the spread, which is a passing grade only if you grade on a very generous curve. The biggest miss: we had What The Buck?! by 10 over Owen's fave, and it won by 34.3. That's juuust a bit outside. We also had Hurts, Donut? by 17, and it lost, though in our defense we didn't know its bench would be playing for the other side.
The best call was Sunday Scaries by 12. It won by 14.8, missing us by 2.8, the one moment all week we looked like we knew what we were doing. Frame it.
Greg Holmgren has won six of the league's 13 titles, including three straight with Bailey's Bad Boys 2. Nobody else has more than two. That's not a league; that's a residency.
The Week 9 record is 184.3, set by Lee Buckner's What The Buck?! in 2022. This week's high was 138.8, so the record can sleep soundly.
The Week 9 floor is 32.2, Caleb Knepper in 2017. Owen's fave posted the lowest score this week and still more than tripled it. Owen's fave, you are not history. You are just last.
Fifteen claims this week, no trades, and four defenses changing hands. Don't Touchdown There got 19.0 from the 49ers D/ST in its first week, the best thing that happened to that roster all Sunday. Old Goat claimed three players: Malik Willis started and scored 3.8, Jonah Coleman sat and scored 18.8, and Brandon Aiyuk sat and scored 0.0. Claiming a running back to leave him on the bench is buying a Peloton to hang laundry on.
The season's best pickup so far is Tyler Shough for The Commish: 122.4 started points across seven starts since Week 2. Not bad for a guy nobody had to bid on.
Two years ago this week, in Week 9 of 2024, Cord Bear sent T.J. Hockenson, Deebo Samuel Sr. and Harrison Butker to Greg Holmgren for Tyler Lockett and Travis Kelce. Kelce alone started for 306.8 points on Cord Bear's side; Greg Holmgren's three combined for 92.0. Cord Bear won that trade in a landslide. Greg Holmgren won the 2024 title anyway. And Kelce? This week he sat on The Tasers' bench for 17.3.
The Beat · The Tasers
1-8 · 106.2 scored · 133.1 optimal
This week The Tasers got the top individual score in the league from Kenneth Walker III, picked up a Giants D/ST that put up 14.0 in its first week, and lost to Sunday Scaries anyway. The best lineup on the roster would have won. The one they set left 26.9 on the bench, with Travis Kelce's 17.3 the costliest seat. Meanwhile, two of the starters were Ladd McConkey at 0.0 and Jameson Williams at 5.0. That's not a lineup. That's a dare.
And this isn't one bad Sunday. The Tasers have lost seven games this season that their best lineup would have won, the most in the league, and have left more on the bench than anyone. They are 1-8, and the lineup card is responsible for most of the eight.
In fairness, and we ration fairness: The Tasers are also the unluckiest team in the league, and on Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard's schedule they'd be 5-4. But luck didn't set the lineup. You're killing me, Tasers.
“The Tasers don't need a better roster. They need someone to read the one they have.”
| Team | Record | PF |
|---|---|---|
| Hurts, Donut? | 8-1 | 1397.5 |
| Old Goat | 6-3 | 1091.0 |
| Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard | 5-4 | 1172.4 |
| Sunday Scaries | 5-4 | 1149.8 |
| The Commish | 5-4 | 1117.0 |
| What The Buck?! | 5-4 | 1108.4 |
| Don't Touchdown There | 4-5 | 1086.3 |
| HotOnes18 | 3-6 | 1033.6 |
| Owen's fave | 3-6 | 894.4 |
| The Tasers | 1-8 | 980.6 |
Hurts, Donut? lost and still leads by two games. If you ain't first, you're last, which makes it a long, crowded afternoon for the four teams stuck at 5-4. Old Goat sits second on a full win of luck, and nobody is asking it to give any back.
In another league? : a free sample for theirs, or 20% off the season.
Roll the Tape
End of reel · Bear Essentials AI, LLC
Or try a week free · A weekly newspaper for your fantasy league · Your account · Privacy · Terms