The Draft, Revisited · 2026

Roll the Tape

Your draft, regraded

Bear Down or Get Chopped · Through Week 8

RT-002A

The Draft, Revisited

Cana's Competitive Team Aced the Draft. Dolly's Follies Lived Up to Its Name.

Halfway through the season, the draft gets its real grade: an A+ at the top, an F at the bottom, and a warning label on anything named Hope.

Cana's Competitive Team drafted Josh Allen 13th and watched him become the third-best player in the whole draft. Then it took Tee Higgins in the third round, and he ranks 22nd. Then, in the twelfth round, Geno Smith, who ranks 57th. Every point this team has started came from its own picks, which in an eighteen-team guillotine league is either brilliance or witchcraft. We are not ruling out witchcraft.

The top of the curve belongs to a draft that finished 255.9 points above what its slots produced in a redraft. Like Tim Taylor demanding more power, it kept pushing, and for once nothing caught fire. Suspicious? Extremely. First place on a curve earns an audit, not a parade.

At the other end, Dolly's Follies drafted its way to the only F on the board. Its first-rounder, Drake London, was taken 18th and ranks 47th, and he is not even its worst pick. Some teams name themselves after what they hope to become. Dolly's Follies named itself after what it would do.

255.9Points Cana's Competitive Team beat its draft slots by
202Spots Kirk Cousins outran his draft slot
177Where the 10th pick, De'Von Achane, ranks now
RT-003A

The Grades

Halfway through the season (through Week 8), every pick graded on what he has scored since, on a curve. Vs par: points above or below what those slots produced in a redraft. From the draft: the share of the team’s started points from its own picks.

#TeamGradePtsVs parFrom the draft
1Cana's Competitive Team
Allen taken 13th, Geno 204th. Top of the curve, top of our suspect list.
A+1113.7+255.9100%
2Fetid Lady Farts
Kirk Cousins in round 12, ranks 8th. Quentin Johnston ranks 188th. Balance!
A1014.3+155.9100%
3The Indiana Bears
Jordan Love taken 148th, ranks 13th. Then Michael Pittman Jr. ranks 191st, like a punchline.
A1017.4+15285%
4Tyler's Top Team
Jordyn Tyson: 0.0 points from round 10. A spotless record, technically.
A-1056.5+143.993%
5Dawg Pound
Emeka Egbuka taken 38th, ranks 98th. Round-11 Aaron Rodgers is still covering for it.
B+999.8+108.393%
6Jared's Scary Team
Owns redraft No. 1 and still a B+. Breece Hall taken 34th, ranks 155th.
B+967+83.378%
7Ole Goat
CeeDee Lamb earns his slot; Courtland Sutton, taken 59th, ranks 140th, earns a demotion.
B924.7+70.466%
8max 's Magnificent Team
TreVeyon Henderson taken 100th, ranks 165th. 'Magnificent' is pulling a lot of weight.
B-918.6+65.991%
9Chef Daddy
Nico Collins taken 15th, ranks 89th. Round-13 DeMario Douglas outscored the entrée.
B-890.1+36.680%
10Unlimited Victory
Travis Etienne Jr. taken 41st, ranks 169th. Victory remains strictly limited.
C+832.4−32.8100%
11Whodey Special
Jadarian Price: fourth round, 14.0 points. The special is not recommended tonight.
C+783.5−61.6100%
12Andrew's Astounding Team
Saquon Barkley taken 11th, ranks 137th. Astounding, yes. Just not the good kind.
C770−85.185%
13Protein Farts
Worst pick in five different rounds. That's not a draft, that's a pattern.
C-729.3−119.584%
14Sam's Super Team
Alec Pierce taken 80th, ranks 199th. Waivers and trades handle the super part.
C-725.2−13365%
15Cord’s Last Hope
De'Von Achane taken 10th, ranks 177th. The team name was a warning label.
D+706−146.8100%
16Bloody Pfharts
Jonathon Brooks taken 103rd, ranks 206th. Saved by the wire: Winston and Penix.
D708−149.781%
17Valenta Bear
A.J. Brown taken 25th, ranks 185th. Jared Goff is carrying the whole cave.
D698.1−159.370%
18Dolly's Follies
MarShawn Lloyd taken 90th, ranks 164th. Last on the curve. The name was a confession.
F661.6−184.4100%

Exactly half the league beat its draft slots, and the other half is down there with Dolly's Follies, which finished -184.4 under its own.

RT-004A

Steals and Busts

The steals: taken late, playing early

PlayerTeamWentRanksPts
Kirk Cousins (QB)Fetid Lady Farts#210#8159.7
Braelon Allen (RB)Jared's Scary Team#219#5899.6
DeMario Douglas (WR)Chef Daddy#231#7979.3
Geno Smith (QB)Cana's Competitive Team#204#5799.6
Bryce Young (QB)Fetid Lady Farts#174#35126.2
Aaron Rodgers (QB)Dawg Pound#182#46112.3

The busts: early picks, late returns

PlayerTeamWentRanksPts
De'Von Achane (RB)Cord’s Last Hope#10#17724.6
A.J. Brown (WR)Valenta Bear#25#18519.1
De'Zhaun Stribling (WR)Protein Farts#93#2340
Jadarian Price (RB)Whodey Special#56#19514
Travis Etienne Jr. (RB)Unlimited Victory#41#16930.9
Saquon Barkley (RB)Andrew's Astounding Team#11#13750.5

Fetid Lady Farts took Kirk Cousins 210th and he ranks 8th, the best steal of the draft. Cord’s Last Hope spent the 10th overall pick on De'Von Achane, who ranks 177th: less a pick than a donation.

RT-005A

The Redraft

The draft as it should have gone: everyone drafted, ranked by what they’ve scored.

#PlayerPtsWentDrafted by
1Jaxon Smith-Njigba (WR)220#3Jared's Scary Team
2Jahmyr Gibbs (RB)195.8#1Tyler's Top Team
3Josh Allen (QB)187.8#13Cana's Competitive Team
4Joe Burrow (QB)169.6#72Tyler's Top Team
5CeeDee Lamb (WR)168.3#14Ole Goat
6Drake Maye (QB)160.9#64max 's Magnificent Team
7Kenneth Walker III (RB)160.1#28max 's Magnificent Team
8Kirk Cousins (QB)159.7#210Fetid Lady Farts
9Bijan Robinson (RB)153.3#2Dawg Pound
10D'Andre Swift (RB)150.7#62Andrew's Astounding Team
11Trey McBride (TE)150.4#17Whodey Special
12Kyren Williams (RB)150#24Cana's Competitive Team
13Jordan Love (QB)148.8#148The Indiana Bears
14Dak Prescott (QB)147.9#57Protein Farts
15Christian Watson (WR)146.8#83Andrew's Astounding Team
16Brock Purdy (QB)146#123Chef Daddy
17Jonathan Taylor (RB)144.2#8Sam's Super Team
18Christian McCaffrey (RB)144#4The Indiana Bears

Jaxon Smith-Njigba goes first in the do-over, two spots ahead of where Jared's Scary Team grabbed him. The biggest climb into the top of the board is Kirk Cousins, from the twelfth round to 8th, a Kramer entrance nobody saw coming.

RT-006A

The First Round

Every first-round pick, and where he ranks now.

PickPlayerTeamRanksPts
#1Jahmyr Gibbs (RB)Tyler's Top Team#2195.8
#2Bijan Robinson (RB)Dawg Pound#9153.3
#3Jaxon Smith-Njigba (WR)Jared's Scary Team#1220
#4Christian McCaffrey (RB)The Indiana Bears#18144
#5Ja'Marr Chase (WR)Unlimited Victory#34128.2
#6Amon-Ra St. Brown (WR)Bloody Pfharts#20141
#7James Cook III (RB)Fetid Lady Farts#29131.7
#8Jonathan Taylor (RB)Sam's Super Team#17144.2
#9Puka Nacua (WR)max 's Magnificent Team#23138.6
#10De'Von Achane (RB)Cord’s Last Hope#17724.6
#11Saquon Barkley (RB)Andrew's Astounding Team#13750.5
#12Justin Jefferson (WR)Valenta Bear#6986.4
#13Josh Allen (QB)Cana's Competitive Team#3187.8
#14CeeDee Lamb (WR)Ole Goat#5168.3
#15Nico Collins (WR)Chef Daddy#8976.1
#16Omarion Hampton (RB)Protein Farts#12062.2
#17Trey McBride (TE)Whodey Special#11150.4
#18Drake London (WR)Dolly's Follies#47109.8

Fewer than half of this first round would go in the first round today; Achane, Barkley and Nico Collins got tossed out the front door like Jazz on The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air. Meanwhile Josh Allen and CeeDee Lamb went late in the round and both rank inside the top five, so the early pickers paid extra for the privilege of being wrong first.

RT-007A

Off the Wire

The best seasons by players nobody drafted.

PlayerPtsFound by
Emanuel Wilson (RB)65.3Andrew's Astounding Team
Ollie Gordon II (RB)57The Indiana Bears
Jameis Winston (QB)56.3Bloody Pfharts
Deshaun Watson (QB)54.8Dawg Pound
Michael Penix Jr. (QB)49.6Bloody Pfharts

Andrew's Astounding Team found the best season nobody drafted, Emanuel Wilson's 65.3 points, and like the volleyball in Cast Away, its Wilson has been better company than its first-round Saquon Barkley.

RT-008A

The Verdict

The lesson in this league: quarterbacks fall off the back of the truck. Kirk Cousins, Geno Smith, Jordan Love and Aaron Rodgers all went after the eighth round and all outran their slots by triple digits. Tyler's Top Team has started more points from its own picks than anyone, and Cana's Competitive Team never needed the wire at all.

At the other end, Sam's Super Team and Ole Goat lean hardest on waivers and trades, and the drafts at Cord’s Last Hope, Valenta Bear and Dolly's Follies are holding up very little. It's only halftime, so De'Von Achane and A.J. Brown can still turn. So you're telling me there's a chance? There is. In a league with a blade, it only counts if your team is still around to cash it.

Cana's Competitive Team drafted like it had the answers. Dolly's Follies drafted like it had the name.

In another league? : a free sample for theirs, or 20% off the season.

Roll the Tape

End of reel · Bear Essentials AI, LLC

Spot a mistake? Report an error

In another league? Get it there for 20% off →

Or try a week free · A weekly newspaper for your fantasy league · Your account · Privacy · Terms