Reel No. 4 · Week 4 · 2026
Your league, reviewed
1000 Miles From Home · Week 4
The Front Page
The Commish went from the lowest score in the league to the highest. It posted 157.5, a 9-0 all-play, and 95.8% efficiency, and beat the defending champion by 51.28. Hurts, Donut? won again. For the first time this season, it was not the best team doing it.
Seven days ago The Commish scored 103.1, the bottom of the Week 3 board. On Sunday it scored 157.5, the top of the Week 4 board, and beat every lineup in the league. It also set its lineup almost perfectly. At 95.8% efficiency it left 6.9 on the bench. The victim was Old Goat, last season’s champion. Old Goat’s best possible lineup, 150.8, still would not have caught it. That result was not about the draw. The Commish was simply better.
The other story is a slow leak at the top. Hurts, Donut? had the high score in each of the first three weeks: 192.6, then 184.4, then 171.0. This week it scored 138.2, its lowest of the season, and went 6-3 against the field. It sat T.J. Hockenson on 24.9 and ran 82.7%. It still beat HotOnes18 by 60.52, the widest margin of the week, and it is still the only unbeaten team at 4-0. The champion-in-waiting has had an off week and won by sixty. That is the problem for everyone else.
The exit tape: who left early, and whether it mattered.
RB Saquon Barkley, The Tasers. He was hurt in the 1st quarter at 11:48 and did not return. He finished with 2.0. The Tasers won anyway, which was mostly down to the other team.
WR Ja’Marr Chase, Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard. He was hurt in the 2nd quarter at 12:11 and did not return. He finished with 5.7. The Graveyard lost to the Tasers by 4.84. Both of the week’s injury exits came out of the same fantasy matchup, and it went to the team whose starter left earlier.
| Performer | Pos | Team | Pts |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tetairoa McMillan | WR | The Commish | 45.2 |
| CeeDee Lamb | WR | Sunday Scaries | 41.3 |
| Kyren Williams | RB | Don’t Touchdown There | 36.7 |
| Kenneth Walker III | RB | The Tasers | 30.9 |
| Nico Collins | WR | Don’t Touchdown There | 30.8 |
| Puka Nacua | WR | What The Buck?! | 27.7 |
| Bijan Robinson | RB | Old Goat | 27.7 |
| Tee Higgins | WR | Owen’s fave | 26.7 |
Don’t Touchdown There had two of the top five performers, Kyren Williams at 36.7 and Nico Collins at 30.8, and lost. Bijan Robinson’s 27.7 went into a 51-point defeat. The unbeaten leader, Hurts, Donut?, does not appear on the list at all.
Lee Buckner owns both ends of Week 4 history. The BUCK Stops Here put up the all-time Week 4 high, 193.0, in 2016. Three years later it put up the all-time Week 4 low, 44.1. Same manager, same team name, both records.
Greg Holmgren has six of the league’s 13 championships, including every title since 2020 except one. The exception was Sam Bowers and Hurts, Donut? in 2023. That team is 4-0 now, though its score has dropped every single week.
HotOnes18’s 77.6 was the lowest score of the week and still nowhere near the Week 4 floor of 44.1. It ran 88.8% efficiency, and its best possible lineup was 87.4. Nobody misplaced anything. There was just nothing there.
There were 13 pickups this week and no trades. The defenses earned their keep: Greg Holmgren’s Vikings D/ST and Lee Buckner’s Packers D/ST each started and scored 10.0. The better story is the claims that stayed on the bench. Sam Bowers added Alvin Kamara, who scored 22.8 among the reserves. Japheth Bear’s Ollie Gordon II scored 18.0 on the bench and became The Commish’s costliest sit, in a week The Commish barely needed him.
Japheth Bear also holds the best pickup of the season so far: Tyler Shough, a Week 2 addition with 62.1 points across 3 starts. Second on that list is Harmony Bear’s Dalton Schultz, with 34.9 so far. This week he started and scored 2.9.
Three years ago this week, Forrest Stump and Greg Holmgren made a trade. Stump got Jordan Love and Josh Jacobs, and they went on to score 314.3 started points. Holmgren got Joe Burrow and Joe Mixon for 188.8, and Burrow was eventually dropped. Stump won the deal by 50.4 in value. Holmgren has won two titles since, so he appears to have recovered.
The Beat · Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard
1-8 all-play · 98.4 scored · 140.1 optimal
It would be easy to file this one under bad luck. Ja’Marr Chase went down in the second quarter at 12:11, did not return, and finished on 5.7. The Graveyard lost by 4.84. Case closed, apparently.
It isn’t, though. Malik Nabers scored 23.2 on the bench, the Graveyard’s costliest sit. Dalton Kincaid started and scored 1.7. The lineup ran at 70.2%, left 41.7 unused, and the optimal card was 140.1. That would have beaten not only the Tasers but most of the league. This is one of three teams whose best lineup would have flipped its result. Of the three, it lost by the least.
The season so far fits the pattern: 88.7, then 163.6, then 139.9, then 98.4. The Graveyard sits at 1-3 with more points than two of the 2-2 teams. The roster is not the issue. The issue is which half of it gets started each week.
“The injury cost them the game on paper. The bench had already cost it by kickoff.”
| Team | Record | PF |
|---|---|---|
| Hurts, Donut? | 4-0 | 686.2 |
| Sunday Scaries | 3-1 | 558.3 |
| The Commish | 3-1 | 507.9 |
| Old Goat | 2-2 | 502.5 |
| What The Buck?! | 2-2 | 456.3 |
| HotOnes18 | 2-2 | 429.2 |
| Brown’s Quarterback Graveyard | 1-3 | 490.7 |
| The Tasers | 1-3 | 489.4 |
| Don’t Touchdown There | 1-3 | 489.3 |
| Owen’s fave | 1-3 | 393.4 |
The Graveyard, the Tasers and Don’t Touchdown There are all 1-3, separated by less than two points of PF, and all three have outscored HotOnes18 at 2-2. At the top, Hurts, Donut? has scored less every week, and its points lead over the field has still grown.
In another league? : a free sample for theirs, or 20% off the season.
Roll the Tape
End of reel · Bear Essentials AI, LLC
Or try a week free · A weekly newspaper for your fantasy league · Your account · Privacy · Terms